EarthRef.org Reference Database (ERR)
Development and Maintenance by the EarthRef.org Database Team

Detailed Reference Information
Varotsos & Lazaridou 1996
Varotsos, P. and Lazaridou, M. (1996). Reply to “Statistical tests of VAN earthquake predictions: Comments and reflections,” by Y. Kagan and D.D. Jackson. Geophysical Research Letters 23: doi: 10.1029/96GL00912. issn: 0094-8276.

In this Reply we restrict ourselves to those points that are again raised by Kagan and Jackson [1996>, although we discussed them in our separate Replies to the papers by Kagan [1996> and Jackson [1996>. For example, we show, with precise quotations, that their claim: ''...most of the VAN parameters have been adjusted after the 1987--1989 test period, i.e., retroactively'' does not hold. On the other hand, we do agree with their main conclusion that ''the diversity of views on these subjects suggests that the seismological community needs a general strategy for evaluating earthquake prediction methods.'' Such a strategy, can now be followed for the evaluation of the VAN predictions published to date (which cover the continuous 9 year period 1987--1995), instead of restricting ourselves to the period 1987--1989 discussed in this debate. Kagan and Jackson [1996> also proceeded to a comparison of test results by Aceves et al. [1996> and by Kagan [1996>, and concluded that both tests agree that VAN outperforms a Poisson null hypothesis, if aftershocks are left in the catalog or only partially removed. On the other hand, Kagan and Jackson [1996> claim that the VAN method does not outperform the Poisson null hypothesis ''if aftershocks are more fully removed.'' However, we clarify that the following happens in the ''declustering'' procedure of the latter case: successful predictions of main shocks are also eliminated, and furthermore, we have conversion of successful predictions to failures; our remarks are in basic agreement with those made by Aceves et al. [1996>. ¿ American Geophysical Union 1996

BACKGROUND DATA FILES

Abstract

Keywords
Seismology, Seismic hazard assessment and prediction, Seismology, Seismicity and seismotectonics
Journal
Geophysical Research Letters
http://www.agu.org/journals/gl/
Publisher
American Geophysical Union
2000 Florida Avenue N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20009-1277
USA
1-202-462-6900
1-202-328-0566
service@agu.org
Click to clear formClick to return to previous pageClick to submit