Current models of ocean island basalt (OIB) Pb isotope systematics based on long-term isolation of recycled oceanic crust (with or without sediment) are not supported by solutions to both terrestrial Pb paradoxes. It follows that the linear arrays of OIB data in Pb isotope diagrams are mixing lines and have no age significance. A new model is presented that takes into account current solutions to both terrestrial Pb paradoxes and that explains combined Pb and He isotope evidence in terms of binary mixing. The key feature of this model is a two-stage evolution: first, long-term separation of depleted mantle from undepleted lowermost lower mantle. Mixing between these two reservoirs results in the wide spread in 207Pb/204Pb ratios and generally high (but variable) 3He/4He ratios that typify enriched mantle 1 (EM1) OIBs. The second stage involves metasomatism of depleted upper mantle by EM1 type, lowermost mantle-derived melts. Evolution in the metasomatized environment is characterized by variable but generally high (Th+U)/(Pb+He) ratio that leads to a rapid increase in 208Pb/204Pb and 206Pb/204Pb ratios and decrease in 3He/4He. Mixing between depleted mantle and melts from metasomatized mantle portions reproduces the characteristics of high μ (HIMU) OIBs. The Sr versus Nd isotope array is compatible with binary mixing between depleted mantle and near-chondritic lowermost mantle because of the large variation in Sr/Nd ratios observed in EM1 and HIMU OIBs. OIBs contaminated by subcontinental lithospheric mantle (EM2) exhibit more complex isotope systematics that mask their primary geochemical evolution. ¿ 1999 American Geophysical Union