By definition, ice which survives the summer is classified as multiyear ice. Thus the area covered by multiyear ice during the winter should be nearly equivalent to the ice area during the previous summer's minima. This condition provides a reasonable criterion for the evaluation of ice concentration and ice type retrieval algorithms using remote-sensing data sets. From special sensor microwave imager (SSM/I) data the NASA Team algorithm estimates the multiyear, first-year, and total ice concentrations during the winter using combinations of the polarization and spectral gradient ratios. The Team algorithm provides only estimates of ice concentration in the summer. From ERS 1 synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data the remarkably stable contrast between multiyear ice and first-year ice in winter provides consistent estimates of multiyear ice concentrations. In the summer, multiyear ice concentration cannot be estimated from SAR or SSM/I data because free water on the surface effectively masks the backscatter and emissivity signature of this ice type. From SAR data a technique which takes advantage of the high backscatter of wind-roughened open water as a discrimination feature is used to estimate the total ice concentration in the summer. With a year-long (January 1992 to January 1993) data set from the Beaufort Sea we found that the multiyear ice concentration estimates from the SAR data are stable and are nearly equivalent to the ice concentration estimated at the end of the previous summer. We contrast this with the variability of the multiyear ice concentration and ice fraction estimates obtained using SSM/I data. The Team algorithm produces ice concentration and multiyear ice estimates which are consistently lower than those from the SAR data. We discuss reasons for these discrepancies and the implications of the higher than previously noted multiyear ice concentrations. ¿ American Geophysical Union 1996