Much of the recent debate over low-angle normal faults exposed in metamorphic core complexes has centered on the rolling hinge model. The model predicts tilting of seismogenic high-angle normal faults to lower dips by footwall deformation in response to isostatic forces caused by footwall exhumation. This shallow brittle deformation should visibly overprint the mylonitic fabric in the footwall of a metamorphic core complex. The predicted style and magnitude of rolling hinge strain depends upon the macroscopic mechanism by which the footwall deforms. Two end-members have been proposed; subvertical simple shear and flexural failure. Each mechanism should generate a distinctive pattern of structures that strike perpendicular to the regional extension direction. Subvertical simple shear (SVSS) should generate subvertical faults and kink bands with a shear sense antithetic to the detachment. For a SVSS hinge the hinge-related strain magnitude should depend only on initial fault dip; rolling hinge structures should shorten the mylonitic foliation by >13% for an initial fault dip of >30¿. In flexural failure the footwall behaves as a flexed elastic beam that partially fails in response to bending stresses. Resulting structures include conjugate faults and kink bands that both extend and contract the mylonitic foliation. Extensional sets could predominate as a result of superposition of far-field and flexural stresses. Strain magnitudes do not depend on fault dip but depend on the thickness and radius of curvature of the flexed footwall beam and vary with location within that beam.

Postmylonitic structures were examined in the footwall of the Raft River metamorphic core complex in northwestern Utah to test these predictions. Observed structures strike perpendicular to the regional extension direction and include joints, normal faults, tension-gash arrays, and both extensional and contractional kink bands. Aside from the subvertical joints, the extensional structures dip moderately to steeply and are mainly either synthetic to the detachment or form conjugate sets. Range-wide, the extensional structures accomplish about 4% elongation of the mylonitic foliation. Contractional structures dip steeply, mainly record shear antithetic to the detachment, and accomplish <1% contraction of the foliation. These observations are consistent with the presence of a rolling hinge in the Raft River Mountains, but a rolling hinge that reoriented a high-angle normal fault by SVSS is excluded. The pattern and magnitudes of strain favor hinge-related deformation mainly by flexural failure with a subordinate component of SVSS.