Permian pillow basalts are commonly found in Oman either at the base of the Hawasina Nappes or within the Arabian Platform successions exposed in the Saih Hatat tectonic window. There is an ongoing debate on whether these lavas include normal mid-oceanic ridge basalts (NMORB) witnessing the Permian opening of the Neotethys or if they are plume-related magmas that are emplaced either on the Arabian Platform or on its thinned continental margin. We sampled these lavas from several paleontologically dated middle Permian sites. Four of them (Buday'ah, Rustaq, Al Ajal, and Wadi Wasit) are located within the Hawasina Nappes and are exposed as thrust slices overlain by the Samail Nappe, and one (Wadi Aday) is within the Arabian Platform units and is exposed in the Saih Hatat window. These lavas are associated with marine sediments deposited in environments ranging from proximal (Saih Hatat, Wadi Wasit, and base of the thrust pile of Al Ajal) to distal (Buday'ah, Rustaq, and top of the Al Ajal pile) with respect to the Arabian Platform. Major and trace element features of the basalts allow two groups to be recognized. Enriched high-Ti basalts similar to alkali basalts from intracontinental traps, rifted continental zones, and oceanic islands are exposed in Wadi Aday, Wadi Wasit, and at the structural base of the Al Ajal pile. Moderately enriched to slightly depleted low-Ti tholeiitic basalt magmas resembling the low-Ti flood basalts and those from seaward dipping reflector sequences are represented in Wadi Al Hulw in Saih Hatat, Buday'ah, Rustaq, and at the top of the Al Ajal thrust pile. Both groups show distinct plume-related trace element signatures, and they do not include typical NMORB. Although emplaced in shallow to deep submarine environments, these basalts provide no direct evidence for a Neotethyan seafloor-spreading event in the Hawasina Basin. Instead, they were likely erupted through the crust of the already rifted and drowned Arabian continental margin. Thus, despite their characteristic plume-related geochemical signatures, the middle Permian basalts from Oman were not likely emplaced during the evolution of a typical volcanic rifted margin. We suggest that they originated from a mantle plume which ascended beneath the Arabian passive margin well after the initiation of seafloor spreading of the Neotethys.