Indian plate rocks in the central Himalaya have traditionally been divided into orogen-parallel, fault-bound tectonostratigraphic zones. A straightforward westward extrapolation of these zones has proved problematic in part because of a lack of consensus on the existence or significance of major faults within the metamorphic zone of the Indian plate in Pakistan where more than 10 locations for the Main Central thrust (MCT) have been proposed. We address this ambiguity by systematically tracing established central Himalayan tectonostratigraphy around the western Himalayan syntaxis and across Pakistan. This exercise reveals the following stratigraphic and structural relationships: (1) There is a westward decrease in Neogene shortening across the Himalayan fold and thrust belt such that there is no age equivalent thrust in Pakistan with displacement and metamorphic juxtaposition equivalent to the central Himalayan MCT. (2) Shortening across the fold and thrust belt in western Pakistan is concentrated in the unmetamorphosed foreland as opposed to the metamorphic zone in the central Himalaya. (3) Lesser Himalayan, Higher Himalayan, and Tethyan rocks are in stratigraphic order within the metamorphic zone of Pakistan which appears to be the metamorphic equivalent of Kashmir Tethyan stratigraphy. (4) The combination of early Paleozoic and late Paleozoic tectonism in Pakistan has locally eliminated Upper Proterozoic Higher Himalayan rock and lower to middle Paleozoic Tethyan rock from the metamorphic zone of Pakistan. (5) Late Cretaceous and/or early Paleocene proto-Himalayan deformation in the Pakistan foreland telescoped and eroded stratigraphy prior to the main phase of Himalayan orogeny. (6) Tectonostratigraphic zones are offset in eastern Pakistan by the transverse Jhelum-Balakot fault. (7) There is no evidence within the Indian plate of Pakistan for a large-scale normal fault system comparable to the South Tibetan detachment system. (8) Stratigraphy, as well as the age and tectonic setting of deformation and metamorphism, must be taken into account when drawing tectonostratigraphic zones.