In the falls of both 1999 and 2000, waves with characteristics similar to tsunami hit the southeast coast of Newfoundland, Canada. The waves were large enough to cause local flooding, damage to docks, and other destruction. There is, however, no evidence of seismic events, underwater landslides, or slumping events on either occasion. Other explanations, such as storm surge, also appear unlikely, and local weather conditions at the coast were not exceptional at the time. On both occasions, tropical storms moved rapidly across the Grand Banks of Newfoundland from southwest to northeast, with a translation speed of ≈30 m s-1. A significant, nonisostatic response to atmospheric pressure forcing can be expected over the shallow water of the banks since the translation speed of the storms is comparable to the local shallow water gravity wave speed. We speculate that the atmospheric pressure forcing associated with the storms generated a barotropic wake, and we use a numerical model to argue that as the storm moved back over the deep ocean, the wake was refracted and/or reflected by the variable bathymetry at the edge of the banks and that it was the refraction of the wake toward the coast that led to the unusual sea level events in southeastern Newfoundland. The numerical model results are in general agreement with the eye witness reports. The model-computed wave activity hits the southeast coast of Newfoundland at about the right time and in the right areas for both events, although for the 1999 event the model response is weaker than is observed at Port Rexton in Trinity Bay. The reason for the poorer model performance in the 1999 case is not known, although we do find that the model results are sensitive to uncertainty in the exact track taken by the storm across the banks. The model results demonstrate that the period and wavelength of the gravity waves comprising the wake are, in general, proportional to the length scale of the pressure forcing, an exception being the model response in Conception Bay, Newfoundland, where a resonant seiche response is found to dominate.